This fourth round of sanctions plus one UNSC
presidential statement makes five UNSC actions against the
fundamentalist regime regarding its suspected nuclear weapons
program. UNSC resolutions are INTERNATIONAL LAW. All these UNSC
resolutions are demanding the fundamentalist regime to stop its
uranium enrichment.
1. The biggest winner is the Obama
administration. The Obama administration’s diplomacy was able to
convince Russia and China, two states that have been close to the
fundamentalist regime, to vote in favor of this resolution.
2. The major losers include Ahmadinejad and
Khamenei. Their policies resulted in this major defeat for the
fundamentalist regime. This could have easily been avoided if the
regime accepted the Geneva deal back in October.
From the get go, President Obama had publicly
and privately extended his hand to the fundamentalist terrorist
regime in order to resolve the nuclear issue. Obama was in the
White House from January 20, 2009. Khamenei could have simply
accepted Obama’s offer of direct and unconditional negotiations.
This would have meant doing one of several things. For example,
Khamenei could have personally sat down wit President Obama (lets
say in Switzerland) and directly discussed and resolved the main
issues of contention. Or they could have authorized a high-level
team to sit down and discuss all the main issues. President Obama
sent (at least) two private letters to Khamenei, expressing his
own willingness to directly negotiate with Khamenei based on
mutual interest and mutual respect. President Obama put forth ONLY
one primary issue: uranium enrichment. President Obama left out
human rights, freedom, and democracy as issues of concern in
dealing with the fundamentalist regime.
The question is WHY Khamenei refused to accept
authorizing a high level team to sit down and negotiate all the
main issues of concern. I think the most plausible answer is that
Khamenei did not want to resolve the issues. The U.S. GOAL was,
and is, to have the fundamentalist regime stop suspicious nuclear
activities such as the fundamentalist regime’s uranium enrichment
program. It appears to me that the most plausible explanation is
that the fundamentalist terrorist regime really wants nuclear
weapons and thus actual negotiations would be counter-productive
to the regime’s primary goal of nuclear weapons or nuclear weapon
capability. Therefore, Khamenei used stonewalling tactics.
3. THIS particular UNSC resolution is not very
strong. The only sanction that could cause the collapse of the
fundamentalist terrorist regime is a comprehensive sanction
against purchase of crude oil and natural gas from the terrorist
regime. Due to the opposition of Russia and China, real effective
sanction has not been passed. This resolution, would not cause any
major impact in Iran.
4. However, there is great psychological impact.
The fundamentalist regime tried very hard to defeat this
resolution and said so publically. The fundamentalist regime
really did not want this particular UNSC sanction.
5. Many foreign firms will have more incentives
to leave the market in Iran. Many more will interpret the world
situation as becoming more hostile to the fundamentalist regime,
thus would simply avoid entering the market in Iran. These will
make the economic situation marginally worse in Iran, thus,
undermining the ability of the fundamentalist regime to have more
financial resources to buy off various individuals and sectors.
6. Although this resolution did not approve real
strong economic sanctions on the terrorist regime, there is a
possibility that it would encourage real tough sanctions being
approved by the EU, Japan, and others. For example, if the U.S.
Congress passed legislation prohibiting any company dealing with
the Islamic Republic from being able to also have trade with
American companies overseas or buy and sell in the U.S. then THAT
would have real impact. Or if the EU passed real tough sanctions
prohibiting purchase of crude oil and natural gas from the
fundamentalist regime, that would have REAL IMPACT on the
terrorist regime.
Purchase of crude oil and natural gas provides
40 to 90 BILLION dollars (depending on the price of oil and gas)
DIRECTLY to Ahmadinejad and Khamenei every single year. They use
this money to pay for their coercive apparatuses and buy support
from individuals and groups. A real comprehensive economic
sanction could cause the collapse of the fundamentalist regime.
7. This resolution also authorizes inspection of
ships entering or leaving Iran. In my opinion, this is the most
significant segment of the resolution. This would make the U.S.
Navy interceding any and all ships going in and out of Iranian
ports legal according to international law. This would make a de
facto American "naval blockade" legal because it would be
enforcing this UNSC resolution. If the terrorist regime’s IRGC
confronted U.S. Navy, then according to international law, the
terrorist regime is acting against international law.
8. Minor losers: Turkey and Brazil.
8a. The ruling party in Turkey, the AKP, is an
Islamist party. Many were hoping to see AKP become more moderate
and provide an example of an Islamist party combine Islam and
democracy. The AKP’s embrace of the terrorist Hamas has gravely
damaged AKP’s reputation, although in Turkey it would, at least in
the short term, boost it. Hamas is an extremist violent
anti-democratic group. Instead of working with the moderate
PLO-Fatah, the Hamas seized Gaza and has refused new elections
(because many believe it would lose to Fatah). Many regard Hamas
killing of Fatah officials and members and seizer of Gaza as a
coup.
By allying with the fundamentalist terrorist
regime, AKP further adds to the perception that, it too, is an
extremist group. AKP’s embrace of Islamic terrorists such as Hamas
and the fundamentalist regime ruling Iran, cements EU’s fears of
Turkey.
Had AKP instead embraced Fatah and condemned the
fundamentalist regime ruling Iran, it would have enhanced the
perception around the world that it is a moderate and democratic
party. One could not embrace Ahmadinejad and Hamas and claim to be
moderate and democratic. Hamas and Ahmadinejad have the blood of
moderates on their hands.
8b. The fundamentalist regime wanted to use
President Lula as "useful idiot." Ahmadinejad was using Lula and
AKP to buy time and undermine the UNSC sanctions.